Sunday, August 22, 2010

Scrap Lahad Datu's coal-fired plant!


A posting by Rockybru on Friday, Aug 20 about the billion ringgit coal-fired plant in Lahad Datu near Sandakan, Sabah draws my attention. And taking the Q from him, I would like to add a few lines (or facts) about it.

I wonder whether Che Khalib Mohamad Noh is still one of the directors of Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd who was also responsible in 'approving' the project. And, is his buddy at Tenaga Nasional Berhad, Abdul Razak Majid still holding similar SEB directorship? (here)

If so, both can give a lengthy asnwer to the progress of the coal-fired plant, which was met with criticism not only from people in Lahad Datu and Sandakan but NGOs and environmentalists alike. And the rumors that it was meant as a 'parting gift' for Pak Lah and his friends (who could they be?) has opened up questions to possibility - that it was a syndicated political project.

However, I dont want to go into its depth. What concerns me and many is the fact that the EIA reports was in favor of such a plant, which has been banned in many countries like most in Europe for its devastating air pollution impact.

What went wrong at the EIA agency? Who got the order to tamper with its originally 'obstructing contents' and gave it a 'clear' for the construction of the plant? If nobody wants to answer this, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak will have no choice but to set up an inquiry on it.

Something was not right with the site report, either. It was originally proposed some 10km from the shore but it was then agreed that it must be built by the sea as it would accommodate the setting up of a port for ships ferrying coals.

Another burning issue is that, the Bakun Dam project which is expected to be completed in 2011 should be able to supply enough energy to the needs of Lahad Datu and Sandakan.

The argument is simple - the government, via TNB, plans a 676km submarine cables across the South China Sea to connect Bakun and Peninsular Malaysia, when in fact the distance from Miri to Sandakan is only 480km. Besides, the idea to sell Bakun's electricity to Brunei and Kalimantan has to be reconsidered. Why cant we sell it to the people and industry in Sabah and Sarawak first instead of providing it to other countries?

Maybe we could also consider the summary of the EIA reports here and comments by those who have read it.

Excerpts:

Transportation via marine vessels will generate waste oils and bilge water. If not properly managed and disposed, these will lead to pollution of marine waters. Piling and trenching activities will increase the turbidity in the construction and adjacent area. According to the hydraulic modelling results, the suspended sediment concentrations in excess of 50mg/l in the worst case scenario (during the North East Monsoon) are limited to only within about 150m from the piling and trenching sites (on both sides).


I am not an expert. Maybe Rocky and the rest of you can understand it. But my summary is simple: stop the plan, fully-utilise Bakun's supply and leave Lahad Datu's shores clean and healthy. To those who wanted to benefit from the project, you are doomed!

29 comments:

Anak Limau said...

Parting gift to Tun Dol kah? Aiyama ... penjarakan mamat tu lah. Istana kat Carcosa tak cukup, lu nak perkosa Sabah pulah. Jangan main-main ba .... nanti PRU13 itu BN boleh blah baaaa...

ex-husband said...

is it a 'tradition' to give a project to a prime minister or a minister before he retires?

if so, then i believe hundreds of projects have been given to ex-ministers, ex-deputy ministers, ex-senior govt officials, ect.

do we have any record on that? we should reveal it to the people

Anonymous said...

'a parting project for pak lah...'?

that's interesting, bro. does kj get some of it?

kitabon said...

oi orang malaysia!

apa salahnya bagi satu projek kepada paklah dan pm serta menteri yang pernah berjasa kepada agama, bangsa dan negara.

takkanlah mereka cuma buat kerja sukarela dan membuat orang lain jadi kaya sedangkan mereka tak dapat apa2 'hadiah' daripada tugas selama ini?

fikilah sikit, sahabat.

semua pemimpin ada baik dan tidaknya. kita lihatlah kebaikan paklah ketika jadi pm, jangan lihat sangat keburukannya. kalau nak ikutkan keburukan, pemimpin lain pun ada jugak, termasuk mahathir.

projek macam ni bukan dia sorang yang dakat. dia mungkin daoat sikit sebagai menghargai sumbangannya.

jadi, apa salahnya paklah dapat sikit sebab pm lain pun pernah dapat habuan masing2?

tok nobat, beluran said...

tapak untuk projek itu memang cantik, pantainya bersihnya, pinggir lautnya dalam dan sesuai untuk dibina sebuah pelabuhan.

bagaimanapun, projek ini tidak sesuai kerana akan melemahkan sistem akuakultur dan merosakkan sistem maritim di sekitarnya.

nelayan lahad datu dan sekitar akan menjadi mangsa keadaan, jika tidak dalam setahun dua, dalam lima tahun akan datang.

perairan di situ juga adalah sumber udang kertas besar bermutu tinggi yang dieksport ke banyak negara.

jadi, janganlah hapuskan sumber pendapatan nelayan di situ hanya kerana kita ingin memajukan industri tenaga. banyak lagi tempat lain boleh kita cari sebagai pilihan.

tok nobat

fenin lalat said...

macam tu la kita ni, jai

ada minyak, banyak dijual ke negara lain hinggakan minyak pasaran tempatan tak cukup dan harganya naik.

ada loji tenaga pulak, elektriknya nak dijual kepada negara lain sedangkan masih banyak kawasan belum ada kemudahan ini dan masih ramai rakyat hidup dengan lampu pelita minyak tanah.

entah laa....

a bird said...

that particular are is good as tourist getaway. develop it and the whole nation will reap the fruits.

why must we spoil the nature?

underworld said...

we dont need it.

as u said, fully utilize the power from bakun.

some people do lots of nonsense jobs. thats why laaa

Anonymous said...

jai,

u are making musa aman angry. he is suppose to get his also from that project.

Anonymous said...

bujai, ask kj la. i think he knows better. the project was approved when he was there with his in-law. he must know a lot of things that we dont know.

biol said...

anak limau,

betul tu bah.

jangan buat taik di sabah, bah

projek tu tak baik, bah

sekali air bah, sekali pasir berubah, bah.

abah kau bah!

Anonymous said...

tanya sama itu che khalib hud hud, dia tau semua hal pasal projek ni. walaupun dia dah ke maybank, kroni dia masih ramai di tnb.

guruh said...

u bloggers are bastards!

stop writing about pahlah. no need to dig his past. it will embarrass none other than the malays!

dorani said...

kesian paklah, asyik kena je dengan korang.

kenanglah jasa beliau sikit. jangan dok tengok silap dia ja

20 minutes said...

kitabon.

u are really a pundek.

thats not the way to appreciate a leader.

if he is a good one, ok la.... but not paklah, not kj, not that mata lebam!

u are a pundek!

el condor pasa said...

bujai,

actually people in sandakan need the project, but NOT a coal-based.

we got good lakes and river to be turned into a huge dam to produce hydro-electricity, just like kenyir and temenggor.

why didnt they think of that?

jurugegas said...

i agree that bakun must be fully-utilised to cater for power needs in sabah and sarawak.

whats the point of selling to others when our local people and industry are not fully supplied yet?

dont be a bloody fool!

Anonymous said...

before it gets started, pls call it off, najib!

its a waste of money and hazardous to the environment in lahad datu and sandakan.

lee lap tiang said...

ask kj to answer. i believe he knows every detail!

u takut kj ka, bujai?

chiba-geigy said...

go hydro-power la, u fools!

study the map of lahad datu and u will see some good locations to build another dam for that purpose. its clean and environmental-friendly

Fikri said...

Sad to say that although a hydro-powered dam is cleaner and environmental-friendly than a coal plant, the dam does have an adverse effects towards the surrounding area.

Google it first.

Anonymous said...

Defensive Driving is essentially driving in a demeanour that utilizes out of harm's way driving strategies to enables motorists to hail identified hazards in a likely manner.
These strategies trek well beyond instruction on basic see trade laws and procedures.

With defensive driving classes, students learn to recover their driving skills by reducing their driving risks by anticipating situations and making secure in the know decisions.
Such decisions are implemented based on road and environmental conditions the nonce when completing a sure driving maneuver.
The benefits of delightful a defensive driving group diversify with each magnificence, but often file a reduction of points on your driver’s accredit following a ticket and the assurance that guaranty rates desire not increase.
In some states, taking a [url=http://www.floridatrafficinstitute.com] florida traffic school [/url] class can course a reduction of up to 10% in your security rates exchange for a period of three to five years.
Objective as the benefits of defensive driving classes vary with each submit, so do the requirements. While most primary defensive driving classes are four hours long, some can be as dream of as six or eight hours.

In some states, students hold the election to take defensive driving courses online or nearby watching a video record or DVD, while other states barely allow students to take possession of defensive driving in a classroom setting.
The contents of a defensive driving advance are regulated by each state and are designed to exercise you based on the laws of your state. However, most defensive driving classes hold back similar information.

Losses from conveyance crashes tease both common and adverse impacts.
Roughly 41,000 on annually as a sequel of see trade collisions, with an additional 3,236,000 injuries.
Up 38% of all harmful auto crashes are alcohol related with another 30% attributed to speeding.

The causes of these crashes, emotional weight and price in dollars burnt- on heap crashes are typically covered in defensive driving courses.
The goal of good defensive driving is to restrict the jeopardize of these accidents on becomingly educating students to train injunction and good judgment while driving.

On the roadways, drivers take to take care of with several factors that can affect their driving.
However some of them are beyond the control of the driver, psychogenic factors can be controlled at hand the driver if he knows what to look for and how to handle it.

Defensive driving courses keep an eye on to blurred on how drivers can vanquish pessimistic psychological factors such as unneeded emphasis, fatigue, tense agony and other related issues.
The florida movement school courses purpose resist you erase points from your license. Additional dope want be posted at a later date.

Anonymous said...

Hey guys, my pc is all messed up! I'd heard that a pc program just like a registry scanner might be able to help? Does anyone know of a great registry cleaner?

Anonymous said...

Hi, it's nice here so I am just saying hi. I've been watching forums for a moment now and decided to register. Hope that my english will be good enough to communicate with you :). My hobby are internet contests and my hobby page - [url=http://www.instantempo.pl]instantempo[/url] it's about them.

Anonymous said...

Free website builder services encounter in various styles and templates.
You should be able to utter a website builder with your webhost as any trusted visitors compel from everybody or more.
These websites can attend to arrange for caboodle that is needful on edifice a website.
Free website builder bring into the world made the job of edifice a website easier and less complicated. Flush with the most noviciate computer narcotic addict can under very soon and with no body a site.
Why profit a composition unmovable thousands of dollars when you can with all speed and beyond figure a veteran spider's web placement on your own?
Using a [url=http://www.jkahosting.com] free website builder [/url], you fool the benefit and the advantage of building a dab hand website fast and easy it is still looks businesslike and works as if you paid someone thousands to do so for the purpose you.
Some delicate features with a gratis webiste builder take in trudge and down subdue, gadgets, decoative fonts, shopping carts, and seo help.
A upstanding locality builder should have all of the above. If you cannot build a website and do not demand to fool round with html code than it is highly recommended that you use a website builder.

Anonymous said...

This is just imposible! This exersize is so magnifisent that I just can't belive in it. It works in 100%. Trust ME! Try it!
[url=http://www.ahj.pl/]Joga[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hi
I used this excellent utility drm-removal and used it for removing drm from itunes protected audios a yearu ago, it did the job well, btw. Then I bought mp3 player and it could't play my wma files so I decided to [url=http://drm-removal.com]convert wma to mp3[/url] with drm-removal. It works like magic! Just some moves, you only need to click "Add" button and choose the folder of wma files. They will convert all the files at once at a really high speed. If you have the same problem and need to convert wma to mp3, you should try drm-removal!
I am big fan of audiobooks and actually wonder, if it legal. I bought a book (now its mine!) from napster, but may be its drm and I can't copy it to my MP3 player!! Thats dick!! I can remove drm - but what about legacy?

thanks in advance!

Anonymous said...

wholesale nike nfl jerseys axiotakix
Nike Peyton Manning Jersey axiotakix
cheap jerseys from china axiotakix
http://www.authenticnikebuccaneersjersey.com

Anonymous said...

axotomarvex Andrew Luck Jersey
Reggie Wayne Youth Jersey
Andrew Luck Youth Jersey
UnmannaSmurce